Wednesday, 14 August 2013

The Perpetual Motion Club, Sue Lange - The Review



PMC cover

Elsa negotiates her adolescence in a future where the three pillars of acclaim and achievement in high school are; science (mainly computer programming, not proper science), sports, and music (rock&roll stardom).

The Concept
Look at today's celebrities (ignoring movie stars for whatever reason), then do a linear extrapolation to arrive at what the future at point X might look like if we keep celebrating them most.

Have a smarter than your average (but otherwise normally abnormal) teenager discover her hormones, rebel against society and attempt the impossible.

Fascinating idea that perpetual motion theory is, isn't it? Incorporate it!

The Writing
It is well written and very funny in the early chapters. Nothing revolutionary. I remember being bothered by a thing or two, but I have already forgotten what. Bad critique-r.

The Story
Elsa is a sophomore in high school (sometime in the future), when it is imperative that you start putting a good cv together if you're going to get into a good college that is. Mr. Brown, her geometry teacher, offers her the perfect opportunity to pad up her resume by inviting her to join the science club. But Elsa is at the age of revolution. She decides to start her own club instead - The perpetual motion club.

Elsa has no boyfriend, partly because her hormones haven't kicked in yet, but getting knocked to the floor in the middle of an empty hallway by the tall new-basketball-star tall guy (who Mr. Brown regards disdainfully) changes the hormones part, but also partly because they are no boys in the picture except Jimmy who is proscribed because her mother likes him and because he is a twerp. Jason basketballstar Bridges she shall have whether he be accused of murder or not. It is the age of rebellion, isn't it?

The Perpetual Motion Club will not be recognized as an official club unless it has at least five members. Recruitment Drive. Members found. Now convince the panel. Mr. Brown the ogre.

No matter, achieve the impossible - build a perpetual motion machine. It is the age of discovery.

The Resolution
When you fall, pick yourself up and keep running in a direction as close to the one you were on as you can.

The Verdict
It starts out as a great book for science lovers, promising either a great invention or a recognition of failure as an inevitability in life, and ends up as an overcoming impossible odds in a dystopic world young adult book. Not for me.

Monday, 29 July 2013

Desperate Duchesses (Desperate Duchesses #1), Eloisa James - The Review


Rapiers. Dawn, Wimbledon Commons, near the windmill. Tuesday. I have a chess game planned with Lord Bonnington tomorrow and can’t bother with this. You are a hot-headed Fool who clearly has no sense of the Importance of Women (none whatsoever) nor of a good Sleep (vastly to be desired). I shall, however, resign myself to killing you.

                                  7.5
Roberta St. Giles knows that if she leaves the matter of getting her married off in the hands of the Mad Marquess (her poet dad), she will die an old hunchbacked maid, so when she meets and instantly falls in love with  the most eligible bachelor in the kingdom, she takes matters into her own hands. She pursues the duke of Villiers to London intending to have his hand in marriage one way or another.

The Concept
So what do you do when you commit to writing a historical romance novel/series but you are too gifted of a writer to just write a typical girl meets boy ....... boy marries girl story?

You give us a whole cast of beautifully drawn characters who all have so much interesting stuff going on with them, and then expertly weave into the story, references to and games of that wonderfully elitist, pseudo-intelligent game of chess.

The Writing
Elegant.

The Story
Roberta is twenty one and unmarried! Even more tragic, there are no prospects on the horizon. All the eligible bachelors are in London and she is stuck in the backwaters of somewhere. She is therefore not about to ignore fate when it brings the magnetic - 'He was a dangerous mixture of carelesness and supreme elegance' - Duke of Villiers into her life. He promptly offers her a roll in the hay, not caring whether he shall have her or not. She declares "You shan't have me" and proceeds to immediately fall in love.

Jemma, recently arrived from a life of pleasure, balls, and sin in Paris to bear her husband, the Duke of Beaumont an heir before he unexpectedly drops dead from overworking himself in the house of Lords, decides to take Roberta on as a project. She will take advantage of the fact that she is a superb chess player to get the chess obsessed Duke of Villiers to give up his lady killer ways and settle down with Roberta.

Who have we left out? Jemma's brother of course. And her husband. And her childhood bestfriend.

What have we left out? It is set in late eighteenth century United Kingdom.

The Resolution
After the duel at Wimbledon Commons, near the windmill, Boy marries Girl.

The Verdict
Reading the book is like watching Sergei Bubka jump. You are wowed until you realize he's holding himself back just so he can break the world record again next week. And the week after that.

Tuesday, 23 July 2013

Skios, Michael Frayn - The Review




                                        9.1
Dr. Norman Wilfried and Fox Oliver (Mr.) exchange identities (accidentally so for only one of them) and proceed to take us on a hilarious journey where we are invited to choose to ponder existentialist theories or not ponder.

The Concept
Suppose you write a book with a perfect mix of humour which tickles the thoughts of the mind's eye and humour that overwhelms the vision of the mind's eye, would the mind's sense of humour be grateful or be resentful?

Throw in questions about the meaning of life, the beginning of life, the idea of predestination, the non-rigidity of identity and other questions, to ensure the sourpuss mind without a sense of humour comes away with something as well.

Write the book well.

The Writing
It is very well written.

The Story
Oliver Fox mostly lives up to his reputation. He is a live in the moment guy - see a fork in the road, take it, go where it goes, and if it goes nowhere/somewhere unpleasant, retrace your steps.

Oliver has had his plans for a fuck filled weekend in the Greek island of Skios fucked up by a last minute rescheduling/cancellation.

Oliver sees a fork in the road on arrival at the airport - an enticing, well put together gentle woman, holding up a sign for Dr. Norman (or Wilfried, it has been at least a month, I forget which is which), entreats him with a smile to be the said doctor.

Oliver becomes Dr. (two first names), having, surely, by some act of providence been mistakenly stuck with said doctor's luggage.

Phoksoliva is the unlikely Greek salutation, which alters the course of Dr. Wilfred Norman's (or Norman Wilfred's) Greek adventure. Instead of the pampering his well earned reputation as a sought after, international, guest speaker deserves, he ends up in a remote cabin miles away from any living creature, save for a herd of goats, until he is joined first by Mr. Fox's intended sexual feast for the weekend and then by Mr. Fox's somewhat estranged long term girlfriend.

There's little chance you'll forget at any point in this book that it is a farce.

The Resolution
There is a moment of horror when it seems all the book will leave behind are probabilities and possibilities of several endings. In the end though, we are treated to an outrageous and fantastical ending, which in my opinion takes more away from the story than it adds.

The Verdict
If you fail to have a successful relationship filled with love and laughter with this book, be not mistaken, it's you not the book.